From @Bakky's update on the TEC Committee meeting:
Cllr Booth asked about updates to the published version of CMP suggesting that HGV and LGV (van) vehicles have reduced in volume, and asked whether this seem accurate; Officers do believe this is credible, with changes in the city like industrial sites given over to housing, and that changes were also consistent across geographically dispersed counting sites;
So, deindustrialisatuion in Edinburgh between 2019 and 2024/25 led to a 26% reduction in HGV traffic? Really! There is no way land-use change over five years could produce such a reduction. Think of the speed of change in Edinburgh - which was not exactly some Shenzen style industrial hub in 2019.
Also, odd that the change in industrial sites to new housing was accompanied by a 26% reduction in bus and coach traffic, and a 16% fall in car traffic - you would have expected a growing residential population to produce some uptick in car travel and bus use.
Something seems off about this data. Simply claiming the figures seem "credible" isn't enough. Remarkable claims need remarkable evidence to support them. Until the Council can account for a 26% fall in bus and coach traffic, a fall in van traffic as online shopping grows, and something more credible about the fall in HGV traffic, then there has to be questions about the claimed 16% fall in car traffic.