CityCyclingEdinburgh Forum » Cycling News

"Scottish draft budget 2010-11: a step forward!"

(9 posts)

No tags yet.


  1. chdot
    Admin

    Good and encouraging report on Spokes web site.

    Extract -

    "The full Parliament is debating the budget shortly (probably 17 December) and the Committee is asking that before that date the government urgently looks at the transport section of the budget and tries to reallocate some funding to cycling/walking investment.   Given that cycling investment totals well under £20m, whereas the entire transport budget is around £2500m (of which nearly half is trunk roads) a modest reallocation must surely be possible!  [The Spokes budget submission - which is complimented in the TICC report - suggests a new £20m cycle projects fund, in addition to existing funding sources]."

    Finance Secretary, John Swinney, has ignored transport committee recommendations on cycling in past two years. This year campaigners are more optimistic.

    Still worth adding pressure by emailing your MSPs.

    http://www.theyworkforyou.com - search by post code.

    (If you live in Edinburgh you have 1 constituency one and 7 list ones.)

    Posted 14 years ago #
  2. SRD
    Moderator

    Emailed my MSPs yesterday and got following back from Mike Pringle "Thank you for your e-mail. I have had quite a lot on this subject & I will send on your concerns to the Minister & let you know what his reply is". Rather noncomittal, but good to know he has 'had quite a lot'....

    Posted 14 years ago #
  3. chdot
    Admin

    "Emailed my MSPs yesterday"

    Well done, shame on me.

    Pity he's not more 'supportive', but good about the "quite a lot".

    Certainly his constituency must have a LOT of people who cycle.

    Posted 14 years ago #
  4. Kirst
    Member

    Replies from Margo and Sarah Boyack.

    Margo says "Dear Kirsten,

    Thank you for your email copied to Margo MacDonald. Ms MacDonald hasreceived a number of emails recently drawing her attention to mattersrelated to sustainable transport and in particular, cycling. She will consider them all together as and when this comes to the Chamber.

    Yours sincerely

    Peter Warren
    Office Manager - Margo MacDonald MSP
    PS Apologies that you are getting the standard email Kirsten, however Margo has had a huge number of emails on this and on the matter ofprostitution over the past couple of days and we are trying to clear the inboxes....Hope things are OK with you at the moment"

    and Sarah Boyack says
    "Dear Ms xxx,
    Thank you for your email to Sarah Boyack MSP.

    I am writing to confirm that your email has been received and that I have passed it on toSarah's constituency office for her consideration. You may be interested to know that Sarah produces a monthly e-newsletter to update constituents on her work. I have attached the latest edition for your information and will add your name to the distribution list to receive future editions. If you do not wish to receive the e-newsletter,please respond to this message and I will be happy to remove your name from the list.
    Kind regards
    Chrissie Finnigan Parliamentary Assistant to Sarah Boyack MSP"

    So one says the MSP has had lots of correspondence about this and will take it all into consideration, sorry for the standard email, and one says thanks for your email, we've stuck you on our mailing list! Hmmm. I know which I consider to be the better reply.

    Posted 14 years ago #
  5. SRD
    Moderator

    Now here's a good reply!

    Thank you for your email.

    It is extremely important that we invest in cycling and walking to meet
    climate change targets whilst contributing to improvements in the
    nation's health and wellbeing. I know a lot of people are put off
    cycling in Edinburgh because of the roads, but the more people who cycle
    the safer it becomes and steps must be taken at all levels to encourage
    this. As a member of the Transport Committee I am happy to raise funding
    for cycling and walking with the Transport Minister and Cabinet
    Secretary for Finance.

    As you are aware, Scottish Government has published a draft of the first
    ever Cycle Action Plan for Scotland which has ambitious targets to
    increase the modal share of transport to 10% by 2020. The document
    recognises the need for more funding in order to get more people cycling
    and states that this is an issue being looked at for the next spending
    review:-

    'health experts and academics readily acknowledge that the current
    levels of investment will not increase levels of cycling.The responses
    to this action plan and the evidence from health and environmental
    research will strengthen the case for a higher level of investment in
    the next spending review period which begins in April 2011. The Scottish
    Government will review all current funding streams in order to provide
    scope for consideration of increased levels of investment to achieve a
    better aligned cycling budget across policy areas.'
    Cycle Action Plan for Scotland Consultation, p14
    http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Resource/Doc/273788/0081826.pdf

    Active travel is the subject of a Transport committee enquiry at the
    moment and the Finance Secretary John Swinney has agreed to hold off on
    publishing more material on the cycling action plan until after the
    committee have reported. He has stated that he will be happy to consider
    its proposals. You can read the papers or watch the committee's progress
    on the issue here.
    http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/s3/committees/ticc/index.htm.

    The Scottish Government is taking active steps to promote cycling. The
    Pedal for Scotland event (organised by Cycling Scotland) saw a 23%
    increase in participants in 2009 compared with the previous year. The
    annual Bike Week has seen a trebling of participants in four years, from
    15,000 in 2005 to 42,200 in 2008. Monitoring of how children travel to
    school has also improved with the first SUSTRANS hands-up travel survey
    in September 2008. An online resource has also been developed to
    encourage more active travel http://chooseanotherway.com/

    It's also worth noting that the funding for cycling projects is not
    always disaggregated from other forms, and a number of other sources are
    available in addition to the Active Travel Fund. This includes the
    Climate Challenge Fund which has provided significant levels of funding
    to projects such as 'Active Leith' and 'Recycke a Bike'. There are also
    initiatives funded through 'Healthier Scotland' which promote cycling.

    Nevertheless, I would like to see an increase in specific walking and
    cycling funding and am happy to raise the issue.

    Best wishes,

    Shirley-Anne Somerville MSP

    Posted 14 years ago #
  6. chdot
    Admin

    INDEED

    Even if that is now her 'standard reply' it's good.

    Posted 14 years ago #
  7. Kirst
    Member

    That's her standard reply; I got it too. And

    Gavin Brown MSP would like to thank you for your recent email regarding cycling funding. The Scottish Conservatives are currently discussing the draft budget and Mr Brown would like to assure you that he will keep your representations in mind during these discussions.

    Regards

    Richard Forgan
    Researcher to Gavin Brown MSP

    Posted 14 years ago #
  8. SRD
    Moderator

    Longest reply yet from Ian Mckee, although I think it is fairly classic buck-passing and redefining the question:

    Dear Constituent

    So many people have contacted me about this issue that I have drafted this response. Please do get back in touch if you wish to discuss further.

    The Transport Infrastructure & Climate Change Committee has expressed concern over the budget line of ‘Support for Sustainable and Active Travel’ that has declined from £11.5m to £11.3m. The Committee has asked for the Scottish Government to find additional money from within the transport budget, although regrettably it hasn’t recommended where that money should come from. The Committee is now conducting a full-scale inquiry into active travel, and if this generates costed proposals then the Scottish Government will of course consider them with interest.

    The reality of the Scottish budget however is that the Scottish Government has to work with an £800m reduction in its budget due to Westminster’s recession. This is a real threat to all public spending in Scotland and cannot simply be wished away. It means that all budgets are under severe pressure. Setting the Scottish Government's budget for the year is a lengthy and in-depth process which does involve looking at all areas of spending across the Government and identifying priorities. The Scottish Government sees investment to encourage more cycling as an important priority. However, delivering all our priorities through the 2010-11 draft budget submitted to the Parliament is already challenging, as transport and other budgets are fully committed. I also wish to highlight that opposition parties have so far been more concerned with GARL - the Glasgow Airport Rail Link - than active transport or green issues in general.

    I must also highlight that the future take up of cycling will be affected far more by factors such as the layouts of new road networks through planning policy – which the Scottish Government is in the process of comprehensively overhauling. [Announcement expected Fri 18th Dec] Cycling and sustainable transport are not solely supported through this one, relatively small budget line. Local government, which has received a record £23bn funding package from central government, is responsible for delivering many of the real improvements on the ground, and is generously supported to do so.

    The Scottish Government’s Cycling Action Plan envisages a substantial increase by 2020 towards 10% of journeys being by bike. Consultation responses are being finalised and a copy will be made available to the TICC Committee to inform its final report into Active Travel. Ministers have already agreed that the final Action Plan would take account of the recommendations in that report which would include options for future funding.

    Another national example is the £27.4m Climate Challenge Fund, which supports grassroots community projects across Scotland. Many of these have been wholly or substantially focused on cycling. For example the £300,000 Greener Leith project includes promotion of cycling as part of a campaign to improve the environmental profile of the area as a whole.

    The work of the Bike Station in the Southside of Edinburgh is another excellent example. You can see my motion on this here: http://www.ianmckee.org/motions

    I take this opportunity to inform you that I have marked this motion for member's debate in Parliament and that I hope to discuss the topic of cycling, the progress made by the Bike Station and how this sets an example to companies and organisations across Scotland.

    Yours sincerely

    Dr. Ian McKee MSP

    Posted 14 years ago #
  9. chdot
    Admin

    Interesting update on Spokes web site.

    "There is no sign of the Scottish Government paying attention to the recommendations of the all-party Parliamentary Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee."

    Posted 14 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.


Video embedded using Easy Video Embed plugin