I think every forum I've ever been a member of, has someone who thinks that particular forum is more civil, or better, or more informed than most other forums.
Personally, I've never noticed much of a difference, including here. They all have their fair share of members from across the spectrum of human natures and behaviours.
My rule of thumb is the better (friendlier) forums are the ones where the majority of members feel comfortable enough to post regularly.
As for Haymarket, I find it OK. Yes the trams lines have made it more difficult to traverse safely. I almost always stay in the outside lane heading west. So long as I can indicate to following traffic that I need a bit of space and patience, its not too difficult a manoeuvre.
Of course, it shouldn't take that level of concentration and trying to interact with drivers.
I never feel comfortable or safe if i get stuck in the inside lane.
This entire junction really must be a nightmare for less confident cyclists. It wouldn't surprise me at all if many just avoid it.
I'm not 100% sure, but isn't this part of a national cycling route? No such designated route should be the subject of so many accidents to cyclists.
I'm not surprised many have been tempted by litigation. I do think the council have failed in their duty of care to cyclists with what they have done to Haymarket.