“Hmmm, this only works if you ... “
There’s a long thread (or two) on here about (in essence) commuting time/cost v Edinburgh/elsewhere house prices.
Personal choice and all that, but as with drive v other type discussions in the wider world always involves assumptions (not always backed by ‘facts’) and aspirations and family circumstances etc.
There are people who can’t afford to buy (in Edinburgh) what they want, where they want. So look elsewhere then it’s about weighing up all the pros and cons.
I left Edinburgh last year but don’t do a daily commute.
Once had a job where I went to Glasgow once a week. More than enough commuting for me.