CityCyclingEdinburgh Forum » Commuting

Separate Tool Rolls/Bag between bikes

(12 posts)
  • Started 12 years ago by Wilmington's Cow
  • Latest reply from crowriver

No tags yet.


  1. Easier here than on Twitter wher kaputnik and DaveC have queried why I would do this.

    I've got a saddlebag for the CX bike already; and last night dug out an old Brooks tool roll I have for the commuter. Yesterday I picked up a couple of items so that both could have everything I could need (within reason) to sort things while out and about.

    Kaputnik declared himself old-fashioned and moved bag between bikes. I used to try and do that with the CX saddlebag, but generally failed/forgot/didn't bother for a few reasons. Mainly it was down to the fact that with the Carradice usually on the commuter I don't have space for the saddlebag so don't have a mount for it, but for those rides where I'm just popping out I don't have the Carradice on, so would have to rely on remembering everything I need to transfer to a backpack or the like. Three times I got caught out with punctures where I either didn't have patches or a pump or tyre levers. Always just one thing missing.

    Equally, because I commute every day I had the tools in the Carradice, and a weekend ride on the CX bike I'd forget to move something from the Carradice into the Saddlebag.

    So for this the Brooks tool roll is great, because it can attach to the saddle and not foul the Carradice.

    DaveC raised that he has a light on his saddlebag, and never forgets lights, and so would always remember to move it across. But for weekend rides I'm more likely to be out in the daylight, and so remembering lights doesn't come into my head - they're on the Carradice from the commute, and the Carradice isn't going onto the CX bike etc etc etc.

    Anyway, long story short, one bag on each, which just stays there, and which has everything I need.

    CX saddlebag has: glueless patches; chain tool; allen key set (with torx key in disc brake size, and spanners); mini pump; spare tube; 8mm allen key (for pedals); tyre levers; cable ties.

    Commuter Brooks roll has the above, except the spare tube and mini pump, for which there is no space; and the allen key set does not have the torx key (not needed). It also has a small spanner in addition in the size required for the guards. The mini pump for this bike has been mounted on the frame; and the spare tube... might get stuffed under the saddle.

    Just gives me peace of mind that I don't have to think - I can just jump on either bike and hit the road knowing I can cope with most eventualities (have pondered cables for brakes and gears in there as well, but it's probably overkill).

    Like I said on the 'swerve' thread - horses for courses. This works for me. Other (higher) faff tolerances are available.

    Posted 12 years ago #
  2. Nelly
    Member

    See my tweet below - Carradice SQR sits up high - £25 so not cheap, but good option for swappage.

    http://bit.ly/yBWdBj

    Posted 12 years ago #
  3. The Carradice is a bit big to swap on to the CX bike for a wee 20 mile leisure ride or the like if it's only going to be carrying a few tools - could obviously get a teeny one for tools, but then that still wouldn't mount with the main Carradice on the commuter.

    Nice idea though. The whole point is really that I don't have to do any swapping at all and that even if I got out on a ride with no luggage whatsoever I've still got the tools with me.

    Posted 12 years ago #
  4. Nelly
    Member

    The Rules

    Rule #31 applies

    Although I have a concern with rule #29 now

    Posted 12 years ago #
  5. wingpig
    Member

    I now have a brake cable and gear cable in my bag from my surfeit at home, seeing as they're relatively fond of failing on the way into work. Under-seat bag is swappable between bikes but only contains the cable-lock and padlock (and occasionally spare spare spare batteries) and whilst I don't use the expansion-option zip there's not much space for it to expand into and the fixing isn't massively strong. Tubes/tools/bits/batteries are kept in the rapidly-deteriorating Revolution drawstring bag (which came free with my bike) in whichever bag or pannier I'm taking with me, omitted on short journeys or when I need full bag-capacity for shopping. Toolbag will be adapted to fit on the rack at some point, partly to improve weight distribution and partly to free up bag-space and partly to ease strain on pannier-clips.

    Posted 12 years ago #
  6. kaputnik
    Moderator

    That said, I'm so unimpressed with the falling-apart-ness of the last 3 different under-saddle bags I've used that I am going to get a tool roll instead, that can be slung under the Brooks saddles or carried in the jersey pocket on other rides.

    Posted 12 years ago #
  7. Min
    Member

    Definitely something to be said for this, especially when as in my case your bikes all take different inner tubes.

    Posted 12 years ago #
  8. kaputnik
    Moderator

    3 of my bikes can share 23-25 tubes. The 4th, the touring bike, could share when it had 28s but now has its own supply carried in the pannier for its 32 tubes. The 5th bike will have tubular tyres so will get a spare tyre stashed under seat, in the traditional style.

    Posted 12 years ago #
  9. DaveC
    Member

    As anth has said I move the bag round buy recently the clipped on Smart 1/2 Watt light fell off 5 miles from home and I only found it the next day scanning my route home from the previous day. I now have a screwed on mount for the light so the saddle bag actually gets in the way. I have some thick goretex from a few years ago which I intend to sew into a saddle bag for a second tool roll. I have duplicates of everything anyway and hopefully the new bag will be designed not to obsqure the Smart. On the Cotic I have a long strip (5 LEDs) rear light so its not obsqured by the existing saddle bag.

    I take a light with me all the time as I never know if I wil be back before dark.

    Posted 12 years ago #
  10. kaputnik
    Moderator

    Seeing as it's valentines day and 3 days until pay day, treated myself to this

    Posted 12 years ago #
  11. minus six
    Member

    quite like the look of the new rapha tool roll

    http://www.rapha.cc/seat-pack

    Posted 12 years ago #
  12. crowriver
    Member

    If I'm leaving a bike at the foot of the stairs I generally don't leave anything in the saddle/bar bag anyway, so moving stuff between bikes is a regular necessity.

    I keep a Topeak mini toolkit, patches, cable ties, etc. in a cotton bag which I just swap between different bags/panniers on different bikes. I have to add an appropriate inner tube, plus any necessary extras eg. waterproofs, snacks, and so depending on the ride.

    Posted 12 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.


Video embedded using Easy Video Embed plugin