CityCyclingEdinburgh Forum » Computers, GPS, 'Smart' 'Phones

Retro grouch paper map vs. GPS

(4 posts)
  • Started 11 years ago by crowriver
  • Latest reply from Instography

  1. crowriver
    Member

    More and more people are using GPS devices instead of maps. The way I see it, a hand held GPS device has a lot in common with the One Ring of the Lord of the Rings trilogy.

    "A person wearing the Ring would enter a shadowy world revealing the physical world from a different aspect, and from which physical objects were harder to see… The Ring slowly but inevitably corrupted its bearer, regardless of the bearer’s initial intent."

    GPS devices change the way you see the landscape, they conceal as much as they reveal and they will end up enslaving all but the most strong-willed rider. And like bike computers they tend to trick us into to paying more attention to average speed and distance covered than is healthy when touring. It’s far to easy to become a GPS Gollum: a miserable, unthinking slave to the ‘precious’.

    From: http://thebikeshow.net/touring-tips-6-maps-revisited-computer-mapping/

    Discuss.

    Posted 11 years ago #
  2. steveo
    Member

    I quite like the speedo whilst touring personally, I'm prone to going full tilt until I can no longer keep the speed up instead of pacing my self.

    Keeping the average speed below a predetermined level stops me arriving two hours early and too knackered to ride the next day.

    Posted 11 years ago #
  3. Roibeard
    Member

    I've a preference for the paper maps, as I don't think a GPS can give the depth of detail, or the breadth that a paper map can.

    I've printed out maps on A4 and found them restrictive, A3 is about the minimum useful sheet size, and what GPS has a screen that's even A4 size (iPad strapped to the bars?).

    Similarly, the level of detail appears lacking; to avoid clutter some of the OS "layers" are either absent or routinely switched off.

    However...

    I can see them as being a nice replacement for a route sheet, calling the turns with (ideally!) the level of precision of a rally copilot.

    Question is, do they do that? And in a classic example of CCE thread drift, which ones work well for you?

    Robert

    Posted 11 years ago #
  4. Instography
    Member

    It's not either / or (and he implies as much in the rest of the article). Little GPS things like the Garmin Edge are hopeless to follow a route but I've toured with the route planned on an OS map in the pub, drawn on 1:50000 OS maps in MemoryMap, and sent to an eTrex and it's great. Clamped to the handlebars you just need the little arrow to point out turns (and mis-turns).

    That doesn't stop you looking at the OS map in your bag (who would travel anywhere they'd not been before without one?) and deviating from the route if you want to. The GPS will help you find your way back if you get lost.

    Posted 11 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.


Video embedded using Easy Video Embed plugin