Do you agree with these ones?
http://217.174.251.127/NNs/s2.html?app=apps2/NN3
CEC is doing a survey -
"
Edinburgh Council (@Edinburgh_CC)
03/07/2014 16:33
What's your patch in Edinburgh? Tell us by taking part in our super quick survey
"
CityCyclingEdinburgh Forum » General Edinburgh
"Natural Neighbourhoods"
(5 posts)-
Posted 11 years ago #
-
Interesting distribution. Small number of Massive neighbourhoods to the west of Edinburgh including the non-neighbourhood of ingilston gogar Edinburgh airport. Then big number of much smaller neighbourhoods to the east. Reflects an earlier configuration of Edinburgh as out to the bypass. Beyond which lay other councils. My neighbourhood is clearly the suburb/village where I life so I will be agreeing with their quick survey but will be interested in what others think as sometimes boundaries drawn by organisations. (Councils, health boards etc) are out of kilter with what people living on the ground feel.
Posted 11 years ago # -
I quite like it. Pretty representative to me...but it's always going to be up for debate. Take Bruntsfield ..which historically was enormous but now definitely more constrained by areas which have developed their own identities.
A few quirks, such as Murrayfield stadium not even close to being in the Murrayfield neighbourhood, but I guess you have to draw the line somewhere...(literally)Posted 11 years ago # -
What it misses is this isn't a single layer of identity. Lots of areas are known pretty well, but are arguably also widely accepted as part of wider area.
For example "Leith", "Portobello", ...
Posted 11 years ago # -
@wangi, that is the bit I am interested in. People with children identify with the street they live in, the school their children attend, a football team etc. But not sure structures such as council wards have are something people have an affinity towards? This natural neighbourhood seems to be an attempt to marry up your post code with the area you feel you live in. This works for me as I live in a suburban village that goes into the hills I identify with and is where my kids go to school and this is all in the one monoculture natural neighbourhood. I will cycle further afield.
Posted 11 years ago #
Reply
You must log in to post.
posts
