A raging argument has beset the SRD - Mr SRd household, pitting the senior family members against the junior.
CityCyclingEdinburgh Forum » Debate!
Settle An argument (OT)
(78 posts)-
Posted 9 years ago #
-
The first three Star Wars movies in the 1970s were episodes 4,5 and 6, the ones that came out after this, darth moll etc were episodes 1,2 and 3.
Posted 9 years ago # -
Wrong answer
Posted 9 years ago # -
I don't think so.
Posted 9 years ago # -
Posted 9 years ago #
-
7. Many Bothans died to bring us this information :(
Posted 9 years ago # -
I need to get spytfyre to come back and talk sense into you lot!
Posted 9 years ago # -
Number of what?
Posted 9 years ago # -
I saw Spytfyre the other day but the only classic film series he mentioned was Indiana Jones.
Posted 9 years ago # -
I am not a number. I am an independent non-canon film!
(also, all polls should have 'Beer' as an option)
Posted 9 years ago # -
It has to be four. The 'canon' set up in Phantom Menace, attack of the clones and the other one doesn't fit with the rest of the established SW-universe.
If Disney can claim all the Extended universe fiction is 'Legends' and no longer canon, I can claim PM et al is 'Nonsense' and never happened.
Posted 9 years ago # -
Sorry, no matter how [forum rules apply] the three prequels were you have to count them.. :-/
Posted 9 years ago # -
The real fan's canon, and this is objective fact presented as objective fact, is that the order begins and ends thusly:
Star Wars
Star Wars Holiday Special
Empire Strikes Back
Return of the Jedi
Force AwakensPosted 9 years ago # -
Piffle.
Midichlorians? Nope.
All Jedi looking like Ben Kenobi while was in hiding? Nopenope
C3P0 being made by Darth Vader and never mentioning it once? NopeNope Nopeity nope nope.
I am counting nothing.
Posted 9 years ago # -
I have the benefit of never having seen any of the supposed prequels.
But I am not 'just' making a point. It simply does not make sense to call 1-3 anything else (and certainly not 4-6). So when my kids talk about 4, I always have to say 'which 4? My 4 or your 4'. Hence the argument.
Posted 9 years ago # -
Might I suggest the following:
A, B, C; 1, 2, 3; G4, H5, I6
Posted 9 years ago # -
Episodes IV - VI were Episodes IV - VI before Episodes I - III graced us with their unwelcome presence. Therefore The Force Awakens is Episode VII. Though it's the fourth 'proper' Star Wars movie (even if it was almost a carbon copy of A New Hope).
So it's both 4 and VII...
Posted 9 years ago # -
According to Wikipedia Star Wars wasn't called 'episode IV: 'a new hope' until 1981, so I stand by my position.
Posted 9 years ago # -
Well I have no need to be right nor do I care what number it is? I just checked with George Lucas and he said 7. Also the seventh film made if that helps?
Posted 9 years ago # -
"According to Wikipedia Star Wars wasn't called 'episode IV: 'a new hope' until 1981, so I stand by my position."
The trailers for the 1977 film weren't set to John Williams music but that doesn't mean they were correct in doing so. It's all they knew at the time. If Irving Kershner calls Empire Episode V then it makes TFA Episode VII.
If it's any help the opening crawl of TFA says "Episode VII" at the top.
Other curious film opinions include that one espoused by people who put Temple of Doom at the top.
Posted 9 years ago # -
According to Wikipedia Star Wars wasn't called 'episode IV: 'a new hope' until 1981, so I stand by my position.
Yeahbut. Wikipedia makes it clear that the only reason it wasn't done was because it was felt by the studio that it would confuse people. Lucas always intended it to be 'episode 4' whether or not the prequels were ever actually made. The addition to the opening crawl of the title episode 4 was made long before the prequels ever happened.Posted 9 years ago # -
@srd, what will it take to convince you that you are wrong in this hugely important issue? Sometimes it is the way you can back down in a family argument that defines the dynamic, this can be more important than winning?
Posted 9 years ago # -
Posted 9 years ago #
-
Episode VII, the seventh Star Wars film made, called Star Wars seven by George Lucas - I'm begining to see a trend here.
Posted 9 years ago # -
Doesn't matter, its all about Star Trek any way. Give me an evil Spock beard over a crusty unshaven man hiding on in the desert any day.
/cat meet pigeons. :D
Posted 9 years ago # -
Surely the key issue in all of this is why does Kylo Ren stop wearing his helmet? So irresponsible...
Posted 9 years ago # -
He was wearing all-black anyway so no amount of helmetry would save him in the court of tabloid commenter opinion.
Posted 9 years ago # -
GitS is much better...
Posted 9 years ago # -
@SRD, will you abide by the poll?
I heard way back in the early days when the first trio of films were being released that Lucas's grand plan was to make the first three, then 3 prequels, then 3 sequels. And that is what has happened/is happening.
It is undeniable that love them or loathe them, the Story of Darth Vadar, or TSODV as I will now be calling the second trio of films to be made, came in the storytelling chronology before The Story of Luke Skywalker (TSOLS). That makes the first film in the Story of Rey (TSOR) the seventh film in the storytelling chronology. It is also the seventh film to be made in the series. In fact I'm not sure where you got the number four from in the first place? It doesn't make any sense no matter how you look at it.
To create a shared terminology, I suggest the following
TSOLS can be also be known as LuSk 1 2 and 3.
TSODV can be known as DaVa 1 2 and 3 (and ignored if wished)
TSOR can simply be called Rey or (extrapolating into the future) ReSk 1 2 and 3.
Posted 9 years ago # -
I suspect MrSRD is reading this thread with a wry smile...
On steveo's cat, the ST films are very very hit or miss, and seemingly random. At least with SW you know IV - VI are superb (even accounting for the Ewoks); I - III are undeniably hideously awful; VII was a return to form (though slightly underwhelming overall); so I suspect there will be three distinct groupings (which fits neatly with paulmilne's setup).
Indy? As a kid I loooooved Temple, but as an adult the constant screeching is wearing. Raiders is up there as one of the best movies ever made; Holy Grail is great fun; Crystal Skull sits somewhere with I - III (Jumping the Shark; Blowing up the Fridge; Flying the Artoo).
Love this thread, can't beat a bit of film geekery.
Posted 9 years ago #
Reply »
You must log in to post.
posts
