CityCyclingEdinburgh Forum » General Edinburgh

New Labour transport blog

(7 posts)

No tags yet.


  1. chdot
    Admin

    "

    Sixty ideas

    The transport consultation meeting I organised earlier this month was a lively and talkative affair. As anyone would expect, there were many views of what transport improvements could be made in the city. Here’s a full list of the sixty ideas from discussion that we recorded. Some I agree with, some I don’t. Some are immediately practical, some are not. Some repeat others, some contradict others. But here they are.

    "

    http://lesleydoestransport.blogspot.com/2012/01/sixty-ideas.html?m=1

    Posted 13 years ago #
  2. kaputnik
    Moderator

    Seeing as it's just a random assemblage of often contradictory (and on the odd occasion, seemingly pointless) ideas, I've tried to pull out the ones that might improve (or otherwise!) cycling in the city;

    1. Improved signage to make safer for pedestrians, cyclist and motorists
    2. Reduce the need to travel to work, shops and work within walking distance – keep Edinburgh compact through brown field development
    3. Extend 20mph speed limits
    4. Cycling – upgrade cycle paths
    5. Extend dedicated bus lanes (= car free lanes, my parenthesis)
    6. Proper separated Cycle Lanes on roads
    7. Pedestrianise Princes Street from Waverley Bridge to West end.
    8. Enforce cycle lanes to see they are kept clear
    9. Extend bus priorities by simple traffic management measures (= cycling priority? my parenthesis)
    10. Strict enforcement of delivering mixed use development that permits greater use of walk/cycling for home to leisure (education, health)
    11. Council needs to use the powers it already has to enforce better quality of workmanship, quicker reinstatement on utilities who dig up roads
    12. Extend the off road transport network by using the previous suburban rail routes. Will this be popular with walkers and cyclists? (I'm not sure what this means, nearly all of them are already foot/cycle paths to some degree, my comment)
    13. 20mph speed limit city wide, to make it better for walking/ cycling and safer
    14. Extend tram/light rail from Roseburn to Granton using old rail tracks
    15. Institute a bike rent scheme/safe cycle lanes/dedicated cycle lanes
    16. A council subsidised LPG car conversion scheme to get the cars that do use the city to be greener. Zoned by post code, nearer the city centre, better subsidies.

    I left number 16 in as an example of one of the more hair-brained ideas as all it seems to be is subsidising people to keep driving, parking and being completely attached to their cars in the city centre.

    It will be interesting to see if this can be worked up into a coherent Labour policy for improving transport in the city, of it will just remain a talking shop.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  3. Roibeard
    Member

    @ Kaputnik

    12. Extend the off road transport network by using the previous suburban rail routes. Will this be popular with walkers and cyclists? (I'm not sure what this means, nearly all of them are already foot/cycle paths to some degree, my comment)

    I think he means this will be unpopular due to the loss of cycling and walking routes.

    Robert

    Posted 13 years ago #
  4. kaputnik
    Moderator

    @roibeard - how would they be lost? I assume when the idea says "extend off-road transport" it means for walking and cycling, not for 4x4s!

    But I for one am all in favour of remodelling the West Approach road as a key cycling route! Why we need a section of dual carriageway that leads to a city centre we're ostensibly trying to discourage cars from has always been beyond me.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  5. chdot
    Admin

    Think word 'tram' has been left out.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  6. ExcitableBoy
    Member

    Regarding numbers 3 & 13 - I am all for 20 mph speed limits, but those we have are totally ignored (at least through Holyrood Park and around Ocean Drive, being the two I'm most familiar with. Oh, and around schools at start and end times - these seem a little better respected/followed).

    When I rule this part of the World, all motorised vehicles will have a chip that detects where they are at all times, and limits their speed to the speed limit. Or, at least flags up when they have exceeded it, so that suitable punishment can be meted out.

    Regarding no.7 I would pedestrianise the area between -
    Warrender Park Road and Queen Street (South to North) and Lothian Road and Clerk Street (West to East). Perhaps with the exception of Cowgate/Grassmarket.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  7. Roibeard
    Member

    @Kaputnik - Although your version doesn't mention the tram, I'm pretty certain it was about extending the off-road tram or light rail network, as chdot suggests.

    Perhaps my skimming read in the word "tram" automatically, though...

    <wanders off to check>

    Nope you quote it accurately, however see 24, 25, 28 about extending the tram in off-road routes.

    Robert

    Posted 13 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.


Video embedded using Easy Video Embed plugin