CityCyclingEdinburgh Forum » Debate!

Make Careless Driving a Fixed Penalty Offence?

(7 posts)
  • Started 13 years ago by CompactDstrxion
  • Latest reply from Instography
  • poll: Fixed Penalties for Careless Driving offences?
    Yes, £90 to Gideon! : (6 votes)
    100 %
    No, the current system is better! : (0 votes)

No tags yet.


  1. CompactDstrxion
    Member

    Taken from this BBC story:
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-18438724

    The DfT are consulting on increasing Fixed Penalties to £90, and making Careless Driving an FPN offence. The idea being that the current process of prosecuting Careless Driving is overly bureaucratic and so it rarely happens.

    I think I like this idea, it could result in cyclists with helmet cameras becoming very lucrative to the Exchequer.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  2. amir
    Member

    I would like to see points off the licence, or even suspension. I don't care so much about punishing the careless driver as getting them off the roads

    Posted 13 years ago #
  3. steveo
    Member

    I suppose the only risk is that dangerous driving is (even more often) traded down to careless driving and fpn issued instead of dealing with paperwork.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  4. Dave
    Member

    It's like the introduction of "death by careless driving".

    Did it result in a lot of "death by dangerous driving" cases being downgraded to reduce the punishment for the perpetrator, or did it promote justice for victims by reflecting that the driver has taken a life in what would otherwise be a very mild conviction of "careless driving" only?

    Given they note that driving which resulted in a collision would not be eligible for an FPN, I guess I'm OK with the idea.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  5. CompactDstrxion
    Member

    Note- the guidelines for issuing FPNs/training options only apply to incidents witnessed by a police officer. If you want to support action being taken over camera evidence submitted to the police, you should respond to Q3 of the consultation.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  6. Instography
    Member

    In Scotland, the total number of careless driving offences has been falling steadily from 16,774 recorded by the police in 1995 to just 8,506 in 2009-10. Maybe the extent of carelessness is falling. Doubt it.

    In 1995, 43% were proceeded against in court. By 2009-10 it was down to 39%. Most of them are already dealt with by a fine and endorsement. Only 500 of the 3,509 resulted in a disqualification. The average fine was £249.

    Causing death by careless driving doesn't seem to have resulted in fewer causing death by dangerous driving charges. In the two years it's been available (2008-9 and 2009-10 where there's data). There wasn't a noticeable drop (the numbers fluctuate a lot year to year).

    Turning this into something dealt with by the police with a fixed penalty notice would probably lead to more people being charged / issued with an FPN. Does it not say that the FPN would involve endorsement. Bizarre if it doesn't when speeding does.

    Posted 13 years ago #
  7. Instography
    Member

    Also, I liked the proposal years ago to deal with them by remedial driver education. Didn't come to anything in Scotland although I think there's a lot of it in E&W.

    Posted 13 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.


Video embedded using Easy Video Embed plugin