IWRATS goes radge on the Parades and Demos consultation;
Section 3.2
Proposes banning music after 20h00. Edinburgh is the national capital, not a dormitory town. There are occasions where music at night is culturally appropriate and indeed fantastic. Particularly drumming. A blanket ban is not appropriate.
Section 3.3
Proposes processing 4 to 6 abreast. For Pedal on Parliament this is impossible. Participants are mostly on bicycles and space themselves according to speed and road conditions.
Prioritises 'traffic' and seeks to avoid its 'dislocation'. Citizens having access to and using motor cars in the centre of our city have no more rights than anyone else. Pedal on Parliament seeks in some regards to disrupt normal traffic flows for a few minutes precisely to show how inefficient and harmful they are.
Proposes one marshal for ten participants. Pedal on Parliament has had twenty marshals for four thousand participants with no trouble at all. This rule is absurd.
Section 3.4
Proposes avoiding the High Street. This street is ours. It does not belong to the traders located there. It is the center of our city and just the right place for a procession to be seen. Traders gain by the people drawn to that street, but they have no right to treat the area as a private shopping center. None at all.
Section 3.6
Proposes that organisers exclude those having taken drugs. How are we to identify these people exactly?
Proposes that organisers are responsible for the behaviour of all participants. Responsible how exactly? Legally? Are organisers to be subject to criminal sanction for the actions of others? Some kind of vicarious liablity? Details please.
Section 3.9
Parades and processions are the right of ctizens. It isn't up to you to tell us how to protest.
Section 3.11
Places of worship should have no particular status. Any deity offended by a human procession isn't worthy of the name. Any religious human offended by a procession should have no rights not equally attributed to non-religious human beings.